The Fifth Avenue Hotel, a dazzling new addition to Manhattan’s vibrant NoMad district, has quickly established itself as potentially the best boutique hotel in Manhattan for discerning travellers seeking an authentic luxury experience. Unlike the predictable offerings of international chains, this meticulously crafted property delivers an intoxicating blend of historical splendour and contemporary sophistication that feels distinctly New York. Set within a storied 19th-century mansion complemented by a soaring 24-storey glass tower, the hotel represents a masterclass in preserving architectural heritage while creating thoroughly modern luxury experiences.
A design vision beyond compare
View this post on Instagram
Stepping through the doors of what might be considered the best boutique hotel in Manhattan means entering what designer Martin Brudnizki describes as a “giant cabinet of curiosities.” The Swedish design visionary has transformed the interiors into a feast for the senses, drawing inspiration from the building’s Gilded Age origins and owner Alex Ohebshalom’s global travels.
The vaulted lobby immediately captivates with its jewel-toned palette, featuring ornate wall panels, painted columns and pink silk canopies that create an atmosphere of theatrical opulence. Rainbow-hued crystal chandeliers illuminate bone-inlaid tables reminiscent of Moroccan and Rajasthani craftsmanship, while corridors become immersive experiences through vibrant wallpaper showcasing oversized flora and fauna.
This eclectic design philosophy pays homage to the artistic spirit of Baudelaire and the concept of the flâneur – the curious wanderer emblematic of 19th-century French literary culture. The result is what Brudnizki terms “romantic eclecticism,” creating spaces that feel more like a fabulously appointed private residence than a commercial hotel.
Historical significance reimagined
The original five-story limestone and brick building, once part of socialite Charlotte Goodridge’s estate, was redesigned in 1907 by the legendary architectural firm McKim, Mead & White as a bank in the style of an Italian Renaissance palazzo. The Ohebshalom family, with deep roots in Manhattan real estate, acquired the building in the 1970s and has transformed it into what may now be the best boutique hotel in Manhattan for architecture enthusiasts. The family’s vision included adding a complementary 24-story glass tower, creating a seamless dialogue between historical and contemporary elements.
Rooms that defy convention
While the public spaces reside in the original mansion, most of the rooms and suites occupy the modern glass tower. The transition between the two structures feels completely organic, thanks to richly hued corridors and sumptuously appointed elevators that maintain the design narrative throughout the property.
Even in a city renowned for its luxury accommodation, the rooms at this contender for best boutique hotel in Manhattan stand apart through their distinctive aesthetic. The Mansion suites feature hand-moulded stucco, crown detailing, and painted wood and glass screens. Throughout all room categories, tiger-striped rugs, pleated headboards, and lavish cushions contribute to Brudnizki’s signature bold palette.
Modern conveniences integrate seamlessly into the historical aesthetic, with all controls centrally organised on personal tablets. The marble- and nickel-clad bathrooms complement the maximalist approach with bold wallpaper and thoughtfully separated areas for shower and toilet facilities.
Suite highlights worth noting:
- Two-Room Suite: A 1,300-square-foot sanctuary with twice-daily housekeeping, complimentary pressing services, and dedicated luxury car service.
- Flâneur Suite: Features a spectacular terrace with a Japanese garden and perhaps Manhattan’s most dramatic bathing experience – a soaking tub overlooking the New York skyline.
- Petite Rooms: Even the entry-level accommodations, starting at 225 square feet, maintain the property’s commitment to exceptional design.
With nightly rates beginning at $895, the hotel unabashedly positions itself at the premium end of Manhattan’s luxury market, yet delivers distinctive value through its singular vision and personalised services.
Culinary excellence as standard
View this post on Instagram
No contender for the title of best boutique hotel in Manhattan could achieve that status without exceptional dining options. Café Carmellini, the hotel’s signature restaurant, extends the building’s old-school elegance while delivering thoroughly contemporary culinary experiences.
Chef Andrew Carmellini’s menu draws inspiration from personal history, classic Italian cuisine, and thoughtful homages to other culinary luminaries. The restaurant setting enhances the experience with blue velvet and mustard leather chairs, Art Deco mirrors, and striking concentric-circle chandeliers. An impressive 1,800-bottle wine collection and sophisticated cocktail programme complete the offering.
For more intimate gatherings, Portrait Bar provides a snug, wood-panelled library environment for enjoying cocktails inspired by global destinations. The hotel will soon expand with The Study, an additional dining space, and a grand ballroom for larger events.
What ultimately distinguishes any best boutique hotel in Manhattan candidate is its approach to service. The Fifth Avenue Hotel offers around-the-clock butler assistance that begins with a welcoming ritual featuring a signature drink and warm towel upon arrival.
Particularly noteworthy is the property’s martini ritual, available between 5pm and 7 pm, where a dedicated martini butler crafts the perfect cocktail tableside. Throughout the property, service strikes an ideal balance – formal yet friendly, attentive without being intrusive, and consistently generous in its execution.
Prime location in a dynamic neighbourhood
View this post on Instagram
Positioned at the intersection of 28th Street and Fifth Avenue, the hotel places guests at the epicentre of NoMad’s renaissance. Within walking distance lie Madison Square Park, the Empire State Building, and the neighbourhood’s burgeoning collection of shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions.
This strategic location allows visitors to experience both historic and contemporary Manhattan, reinforcing the hotel’s position as a bridge between Gilded Age luxury and modern sophistication – a key attribute for any property seeking recognition as the best boutique hotel in Manhattan.
In a city increasingly dominated by minimalist luxury and international brand standards, The Fifth Avenue Hotel stands as a defiant celebration of maximalist design and distinctly New York character. For visitors seeking a boutique experience that delivers both substance and style, this NoMad newcomer makes a compelling case for being the best boutique hotel in Manhattan for those who appreciate distinctive design, personalised service, and a genuine sense of place.
By honouring the past while embracing contemporary luxury expectations, The Fifth Avenue Hotel offers precisely what sophisticated travellers seek in 2025 – an authentic experience that couldn’t exist anywhere else.
Address: The Fifth Avenue Hotel, 1 West 28th Street, New York, NY 10001
Phone: +1 (212) 231-9400
thefifthavenuehotel.com, @thefifthavenuehotel
